Heretic 2024 movie review by Joymahidul

Unmask the Fear and Faith: Full Breakdown of Heretic (2024) – A Movie Deep Dive by Joymahidul

Experience a thrilling story of faith, uncertainty, and survival in Heretic. Our new video explains every creepy detail for fans of psychological horror!

Introduction: “Heretic” (2024) is directed by Scott Beck and Bryan Woods. It is an American psychological horror, smart horror thriller. The film makes you think about belief, doubt, and control. Made on a small budget with strong storytelling, the film features Hugh Grant as Mr. Reed, along with Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East as two young Mormon missionaries, Sister Barnes and Sister Paxton. This gripping movie explores the reasons why people believe in religion. It asks if faith is based on a real understanding or just learned behaviour.

Plot Recap: The movie starts with Sisters Barnes and Paxton, two missionaries in snowy Colorado, trying to share their faith. They get a request from a man named Mr. Reed for more information, which piques their interest. When they reach his house, they find him charming and seem to see his interest in their beliefs. Reed tells them his wife is in the other room baking a pie, and they smell it too. But soon, they discover the smell is from a fire. They realize Reed’s wife is not real at all. With no phone signal and the front door locked, things take a dark turn.

Mr. Reed, played brilliantly by Grant, soon shows his disturbing plans. He puts the sisters in a twisted “game,” challenging their beliefs with talks about religion, faith, and control. He makes them choose between doors marked “Belief” and “Doubt,” testing their faith in dangerous situations. This part is especially scary. Reed asks about the origins of religions. He claims they are just old stories with little truth. In a shocking moment, Reed’s “Prophet” dies in front of them. He is then brought back in a disturbing ritual. This makes the sisters question everything. Reed tries to persuade them that he has found the “one true religion.” As the movie reaches its peak, the sisters struggle to hold onto their faith. They are amid shocking and manipulative events.

Ending Explained: The ending of the film hits hard, making viewers wonder what’s real and what’s not. Sister Barnes is killed by Reed, who claims she was just an ‘artificial person,’ using a contraceptive implant as proof. Sister Paxton then learns of Reed’s cruel plan, realizing he set everything up to control their beliefs. In a tense moment, Sister Paxton stabs Reed, but he fights back, injuring both of them. She starts to pray, showing that her faith is really about kindness and love, not just following rules. Reed tries to finish her off. However, Sister Barnes, who everyone thought was dead, suddenly returns. She kills Reed and saves Paxton. As Paxton escapes, she sees a butterfly land on her hand, reminding her of an earlier talk. The butterfly disappears, leaving viewers to question reality — did she survive, or is she now in another world?

Cast and Performances
Hugh Grant as Mr. Reed: Grant shines in his role, showing a sinister charm that surprises us. His Reed is scary yet captivating, making the psychological games both unsettling and interesting.
Sophie Thatcher as Sister Barnes: Thatcher shows Barnes’s fight between faith and doubt with depth. She adds a sense of vulnerability that raises the film’s emotional stakes.
Chloe East as Sister Paxton: East’s strong and conflicted take on Paxton is powerful and relatable. Her journey from a faith-driven missionary to a survivor is fascinating.

Cinematography and Direction: Scott Beck and Bryan Woods create a visually engaging horror film, pulling us into a tight setting. With Chung-hoon Chung as the cinematographer, the film uses shadows and tight spaces effectively, increasing the fear. His earlier work on Oldboy and The Handmaiden is clear here. The camera focuses on the actors’ faces. This technique draws viewers into their fear and confusion.

Critical Reception and Box Office
“Heretic” premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival and got mixed reviews. On Rotten Tomatoes, it has a 92% approval rating from critics. However, it received a CinemaScore of “C+”. This shows that regular audiences found it hard and divisive. Critics appreciated the film’s smart approach. They commended the strong acting. However, they said the slow pace will turn off some viewers. Heavy dialogue also discourages some audiences. At the box office, “Heretic” did fairly well. It made over $13 million worldwide. The movie had a strong performance during its opening weekend. Critics praised Hugh Award’s presentation as a standout, with many calling it the best of the year. However, some felt the film’s complex topics alienate regular audiences. The movie’s focus on deep dialogue was a bold choice. It does not appeal to everyone. However, it’s a refreshing take for those wanting a thriller that makes you think.

Recommendation: If you like horror that focuses on the mind instead of gore, you should watch Heretic. It raises deep questions about faith and reality, making it exciting and thought-provoking. The film’s complicated themes and great performances are a must-see for fans of A24 horror and smart thrillers. However, if you want simple scares, the philosophical talks and slow build-up might not be enough.

Ratings:
Rotten Tomatoes: 92%
Metacritic: 72 , IMDb: 7.3
CinemaScore: C+
Our Rating: 8/10. Heretic offers a chilling look at faith and control. It blends psychological horror with deep ideas. Although it has some weak spots, it leaves a strong impression that will make viewers think about belief and reality.

Conclusion: Heretic isn’t just a horror film. It examines the risks of strong beliefs. It also explores how fragile human understanding can be. With challenging themes and a haunting feel, this movie is a unique part of the genre. If you’re ready for a film that makes you think deeply, watch Heretic. It will both challenge and scare you.

To Watch The Full Movie >> CLICK HERE

Top 10 Psychological Horror Films of 2024